Anchor Small Firm vs XS Soft: Which Silicone Dildo Fits?

Quick answer

Choose the Anchor XS Soft if you're new to anal play or prefer gentler pressure; pick the Anchor Small Firm if you want a more substantial fill with steady, secure feedback.

Size and firmness matter more than the name

The Anchor name covers two very different experiences. The XS Soft is the smaller, gentler entry point, while the Small Firm offers a larger size and a firmer feel. The difference isn't just about dimensions—it changes how the toy responds to your body and how much sensation you feel.

If you're comparing by name alone, you might assume the Small Firm is simply a bigger version. But the firmness shift is just as important as the size shift. A firmer plug holds its shape more rigidly, which can feel more intense, while a softer plug compresses more easily, which can be more forgiving for beginners.

What the catalog tells us and what it doesn't

Both Anchor models share the same design philosophy: a gently tapered tip for easy insertion and a secure flared base for peace of mind. Both are made from ultra-smooth, body-safe silicone, so they're suitable for sensitive skin and easy to clean.

The catalog doesn't list exact dimensions or Shore hardness ratings, so we can't say precisely how much longer or wider the Small Firm is, or how much softer the XS Soft feels in numeric terms. What we do know is the Small Firm is priced higher, reflecting its larger size and firmer construction.

If you need exact measurements, check the product page or contact the manufacturer. For the purpose of this comparison, focus on the known differences: size (Small vs XS) and firmness (Firm vs Soft).

Why the firmness difference changes the experience

Firmness affects how the plug feels during insertion and wear. A firmer plug provides more distinct pressure and can stimulate more effectively once inside. It also tends to stay in place more predictably because it doesn't deform as much.

A softer plug, on the other hand, feels more cushioned and forgiving. It can be easier to insert because it yields to your body, and it may be more comfortable for longer wear sessions. Beginners often prefer this softer feel as they learn to relax and accommodate a toy.

Trade-offs at a glance

• Choose the Anchor XS Soft if...: You're new to anal play, want a smaller size, or prefer a softer, more cushioned feel that's easier to insert and wear. Start with the XS Soft to build confidence before moving up.
• Choose the Anchor Small Firm if...: You have some experience, want a larger size, or enjoy firmer pressure and a more pronounced sensation. The Small Firm offers a step up in both size and firmness for a more intense experience.
• Not sure?: If you're between the two, consider your comfort with pressure and your experience level. When in doubt, the XS Soft is the safer starting point.

Product facts at a glance

• Anchor - Small, Firm: The Anchor Small Firm is made from ultra-smooth, body-safe silicone with a gently tapered tip and a secure flared base. This gives you a firmer, more substantial plug that stays put and delivers steady pressure during use.

  

• Anchor - XS, Soft: The Anchor XS Soft is also crafted from ultra-smooth, body-safe silicone with the same tapered tip and flared base design. The smaller, softer build makes it a more forgiving choice for beginners or anyone who prefers a gentler feel.

  

Which Anchor fits you?

Best for

• Beginners who want a small, soft plug that's easy to insert
• Anyone who prefers a gentler, more forgiving feel for longer wear

Not for

• Experienced users who want a larger, firmer plug for a more intense sensation